Balancing Jay

One soul ponders Jay Phelan's writings.

Jay Phelan pens a regular article, Markings, for The Covenant Companion, the Evangelical Covenant Church's monthly magazine.   Dr. Phelan is President of North Park Theological Seminary.

I respect Dr. Phelan (we've never met).  I appreciate the way he challenges my thinking, beliefs and conclusions.

But sometimes I feel he doesn't adequately address the reasons behind some of my beliefs. So I'm compelled to respond: to scrutinize, add perspective, and challenge. To bring balance.

The first to present his case seems right, till another comes forward and questions him. —Proverbs 18:17

Thanks for visiting. Click on comments at the end of an article to give me your two cents—or balance me!

Wednesday, August 10, 2005

Wheat and weeds (August, 2005)

Jay takes us to the logical conclusion of a "purged and purified church", where we've "shed the scabrous doubters and skulking sinners," and it really isn't what we want. And with Jesus's parable of the wheat and the weeds, Jay reminds us that that isn't what God wants either.

[Leaving the weeds] makes some people's skin crawl. As Craddock puts it, "What? Just leave the weeds in there with the wheat? ...Isn't there any such a thing as right and wrong, good and evil, true and false? We need to take a stand. We need to draw the line. We need to say, 'You stay and you go.' ... But the boss said, 'Leave the weeds alone.'"

I find myself in situations where I'm torn between similar choices. Do I boldly confront this person, or try some other approach? Am I just being a coward if I choose not to confront it in the boldest manner I know?

When faced with decisions like this, I try to work backwards from the end result. I picture myself standing before God on the last day, and we're reviewing this sitution. Will He say to me, "Why didn't you confront him, let him know what I think of his behavior?" Or, will He say, "You had an opportunity to influence that guy, but you blew it with your strident tone."

Sometimes we can't tell wheat from weeds... [Craddock:]"I thought it was a weed. I do not know a weed from a flower."

I've been wrong each way before.

To ponder: